• Customer Login
1-888-273-3274
GovDocs
  • Platform
    • Employment Law Compliance Platform
    • Labor Law Posters >
      • Standard Update Program
      • Digital Labor Law Posters
      • Spanish Update Program
      • Federal Contractor Update Program
      • Right to Work/E-Verify Update Program
      • Canada Update Program
      • Labor Law Poster Auditing
      • PosterCheck
    • Minimum Wage Solution
    • Paid Leave Solution
    • LocationCheck
  • Blog
  • Resources
    • All Resources
    • Labor Law Poster Compliance
    • Minimum Wage Compliance
    • Paid Leave Compliance
    • General Employment Law Compliance
    • Video Center
  • About
    • Who We Are
    • Why GovDocs?
    • Client Services Team
    • Employment Law and Compliance Team
    • Who We Help
      • Retail / Wholesale
      • Manufacturing
      • Professional Services
      • Financial / Insurance
      • Health / Medical
      • Utilities / Energy
      • Construction / Engineering
      • Hospitality / Restaurant
    • Careers
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Go Green With GovDocs
    • Press Releases
  • Events
    • Webinars
  • Contact Us
  • Shop
    • Federal Posters
    • State Posters
    • County Posters
    • City Posters
    • Update Service
  • Request Demo
  • Search
  • Menu
  • Platform
    • Employment Law Compliance Platform
    • Labor Law Posters >
      • Standard Update Program
      • Digital Labor Law Posters
      • Spanish Update Program
      • Federal Contractor Update Program
      • Right to Work/E-Verify Update Program
      • Canada Update Program
      • Labor Law Poster Auditing
      • PosterCheck
    • Minimum Wage Solution
    • Paid Leave Solution
    • LocationCheck
  • Blog
  • Resources
    • All Resources
    • Labor Law Poster Compliance
    • Minimum Wage Compliance
    • Paid Leave Compliance
    • General Employment Law Compliance
    • Video Center
  • About
    • Who We Are
    • Why GovDocs?
    • Client Services Team
    • Employment Law and Compliance Team
    • Who We Help
      • Retail / Wholesale
      • Manufacturing
      • Professional Services
      • Financial / Insurance
      • Health / Medical
      • Utilities / Energy
      • Construction / Engineering
      • Hospitality / Restaurant
    • Careers
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Go Green With GovDocs
    • Press Releases
  • Events
    • Webinars
  • Contact Us
  • Shop
    • Federal Posters
    • State Posters
    • County Posters
    • City Posters
    • Update Service
  • Request Demo

LABOR LAW NEWS

Ninth Circuit Rules Salary History Cannot Justify Lower Salary

Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on Linkedin
  • Share by Mail

By Kelsey Basten

Published on April 24, 2018

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled April 9, 2018, that an employer cannot justify a wage differential between male and female employees by relying on prior salary alone or in combination with other factors.

In the case of Rizo v. Yovino No. 16-15372, employee Aileen Rizo sued her employer, the Fresno County Office of Education, for a violation of the Equal Pay Act. Rizo complained her salary was lower than that of her male counterpart. The county did not dispute it paid Rizo less than comparable male employees for the same work. However, it argued that the wage differential, which considered her prior lower salary, was lawful under the Equal Pay Act.

The Equal Pay Act of 1963 requires employers to pay equal wages for equal work on jobs that require equal skill, effort, and responsibility, performed under similar working conditions. The four exceptions to the law are when the pay is based on a:

  • Seniority system
  • Merit system
  • System that measures earnings by quantity or quality of production
  • Differential based on any other factor than sex

The employer argued Rizo’s prior salary fell into the fourth catchall exception, “any other factor other than sex,” because her starting salary was based on her prior salary.

However, the court determined it did not:

“It is inconceivable that Congress, in an Act the primary purpose of which was to eliminate long-existing ’endemic’ sex-based wage disparities, would create an exception for basing new hires’ salaries on those very disparities—disparities that and stated, ’Prior salary, whether considered alone or with other factors, is not job-related and thus does not fall within an exception to the Act that allows employers to pay disparate wages.’ Congress declared are not only related to sex but caused by sex. To accept the County’s argument would be to perpetuate rather than eliminate the pervasive discrimination at which the Act was aimed.”

The Rizo decision marks a major shift in how the Ninth Circuit has interpreted the Equal Pay Act. In Rizo, the Court expressly overruled it’s finding in Kouba v. Allstate Ins. Co., 691 F2d 873 (9th Cir 1982). (Kouba held that an employer could consider its employees’ prior salary to determine their wages without violating the Equal Pay Act.).  Also, the Ninth Circuit decision is more restrictive than other Federal Circuit Courts that have addressed the issue.  The Tenth Circuit (Angove v. Williams-Sonoma Inc., 70 F. App’x 500, 508 (10th Cir. 2003)) and Eleventh Circuit, (Irby v. Bittick, 44 F.3d 949, 954 (11th Cir. 1995)), prohibit employers from using salary history as the sole reason for paying a woman less.

Keep Informed
with GovDocs Labor Law News

May 13, 2025/by Jana Bjorklund

Keeping Up with Non-Compete Bans and Restrictions and the Latest Change in Virginia

May 8, 2025/by Jana Bjorklund

Pay Transparency Update Cleveland’s New Law and New Jersey’s 2025 Launch

May 6, 2025/by Dana Holle

Where Do Employers Need to Display Labor Law Posters?

May 1, 2025/by Jana Bjorklund

Recent Changes to Paid Leave Laws in Maryland and Missouri

April 28, 2025/by Jana Bjorklund

Ohio Allows Electronic Display of Labor Law Posters

This Labor Law New Blog is intended for market awareness only, it is not be used for legal advice or counsel.

GovDocs Update Program

Who is GovDocs?

GovDocs simplifies the complexity of employment law management (ELM) for large, multilocation employers across all industries. We offer a suite of innovative compliance products, including labor law postings, data software applications and other program management tools, to ease the day-to-day responsibilities of human resources, compensation, legal and finance teams.

Have less than 30 locations? 

The GovDocs Poster Store simplifies the complexity of posting compliance for employers with less than 30 locations across all industries. We offer a variety of posting products to meet your labor law compliance needs, including federal and state posters; county and city poster packages; and other HR posters. Plus, when you purchase posters with GovDocs Update Service, you ensure your locations automatically receive updated posters whenever changes occur.

More Stories From Labor Law News

CONTACT US

GovDocs, Inc.
1305 Corporate Center Drive
Suite 400
Eagan, MN 55121
1-888-273-3274

about govdocs

  • Who We Are
  • Who We Help
  • Events
  • Careers
  • Frequently Asked Questions

Products

  • Employment Law Compliance Platform
  • Labor Law Postings >
    • Spanish Update Program
    • Federal Contractor Update Program
    • Right to Work/E-Verify Update Program
    • Canada Update Program
    • PosterCheck
    • Intranet Poster Program
  • GovDocs Minimum Wage Solution
  • GovDocs Paid Leave
  • Terms and Policies
  • Privacy Policy

resources

  • Employment Law News
  • Infographics
  • Webinars
  • Guides and Whitepapers
  • SlideShares
  • Tip Sheets
  • Product Sheets
  • Press Releases
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Customer Login
  • Video Center

Stay Connected

Subscribe to our blog for the latest employment law news.

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin
Copyright © 2025 GovDocs, Inc. GovDocs is a registered trademark of GovDocs, Inc.
Return on Investment in Labor Law Compliance Programs – Part 1: Your Inve... New Jersey Passes Paid Sick Leave Bill in State Legislature
Scroll to top